Tuesday, 19 July 2011

Evaluative Techniques & Feedback

        I remember when I was in elementary school, almost all the teachers would say good, good job and excellent to the students. Because at early age, we are allowed to make any mistakes, and we always make mistakes at that time. Then in the high school, only some teachers would give us positive feedback, since some teachers think we are between mature and immature, so most of them would stand in the middle, but not for all the teachers. In the university, since there are always a lot of students in a classroom, the professor would hardly comment on students’ performance. Instead, teaching assistants are more used to do it, and usually, they know students well.

         I am just wondering, maybe the more teachers know about students, the more comment they will give? Also, positive/negative feedback is also relates to students’ age? Because of in the early childhood, children are still young, so their physical and psychological development is uncompleted; therefore, teachers have to be more careful when they give comment to students. In university, students are adults, so they are more responsible to others and themselves. Thus, with positive feedback, they will use it to encourage themselves; and with negative feedback, they will use it to improve themselves. Without comments from teachers, they will regulate their behaviours by themselves. However, in high school, since some students are immature; therefore, giving negative feedback to a student might hurt his/her pride, discourage him/her.

           Giving feedback is an art, giving effective feedback it not easy, not at all.

1 comment:

natasha cortina said...

As soon as I read the seven traps by Mamchur I quickly related back to my own experiences in elementary, highschool, College, and University.

looking back at elementary I remember a lot of good work, good job, excellent effort..followed by a sticker..if you got the sticker you really knew you did well..well at least by my own perspective :)

In highschool these comments didn't change so much...I still got the good jobs, just minus the sticker.

In College, depending on the professor, I started getting more in depth feedback. Those professors who left specific comments on my work made me feel like they actually took the time to read, and critically analyze my work.

In university, I felt like I was back in highschool again, a few illegible scribbles, followed by a grade.

I don't entirely agree with you by separating when certain feedback is given due to age, because I think it really depends on the instructor, however it is obvious in elementary and highschool they are more focused on giving positive feedback to boost confidence.

In college, maybee because class sizes are smaller, they have more time to care about the material they are reading and are truly invested in improving their students abilities.

I did have a "bad" experience with a prof at sfu last semester, where he commented that my paper was one the worst he received...he claimed he was an overly critical analyzer..and only meant it to push us to do better..however I took his comment as more of a destructive criticism rather than a constructive criticism...anyways.. maybe that is why I feel university is lacking in their feedback abilities.